My voice started to shake.

"I cut my hand chopping vegetables and I called out to you. You didn't even lift your head. I slipped and fell on the kitchen floor, bruised my knee black and blue, and you never knew. I had a 102-degree fever and still cooked for you, and you never knew."

"What do you know? You know what games Fiona likes to play, what matches she likes to watch, you know every single one of her hobbies, and then you tell me the two of you are just buddies."

"Dick, you felt sorry for her, having to go back out in the snow. Did you ever once feel sorry for a girl who crossed oceans and mountains for you, over and over again?"

He stood up, his lips moving, and in the end all he said was,

"Georgette, here you go again."

"Right. Here I go again."

I got to my feet. "Every time it's me starting up again, I'm too sensitive, I'm not generous enough. Then go find your generous Fiona!"

Dick's voice dropped low. "You're really determined to twist it like that, aren't you? So what do you want me to do? Delete her? Cut off all contact? Are you saying I can't have a single friend left around me before I've done right by you?"

The tears swam in my eyes, but I bit down hard on my lip and refused to let them fall.

"Dick, the line between a friend and a girlfriend, don't you understand it in your heart? With your brains, with how you read people, you really can't see it?"

"You just don't want to see it!"

"Georgette, are you even being reasonable?"

"Fiona would never do this. She's more mature than you, easier to deal with than you! She doesn't burst into tears at the drop of a hat, doesn't show up once every two weeks and act like the whole world owes her something!"

He drew in a deep breath, turned, and slammed the door on his way out.

The sound of the door echoed down the hallway.

I stood where I was, and the tears finally fell.

I started to pack.

The suitcase lay open on the floor, every wheel worn down to nothing.

These three years, I'd checked it through too many times.

Flying over with my heart full of joy, and in less than half a day, packing every item back in again, one by one.

I looked around the apartment. On the wall hung photos of him and Fiona at a game. On the coffee table was a hair tie Fiona had left behind. On the fridge was a sticky note in her handwriting: "Dick, your cooking is terrible."

The things I'd brought into this home.

That set of dishes he never once reached for. That rice cooker he never opened. Those cotton slippers he thought were ugly.

All of it crammed into a corner, under a layer of dust.

I thought about this past year, every time I'd flown twelve hours to see him.

Planning my route ahead of time, looking up the subway lines, writing down in the notes app on my phone every offhand thing he ever said.

He loved Chinese food, so I learned to cook it. He wanted hotpot, so I carried the broth base and seasonings on the plane.

But he always seemed to find it dull.

While I cooked, he and Fiona were on a call gaming together, doubled over laughing.

I'd say, "Dinner's ready," and he wouldn't even look up. "Let me finish this round."

By the time the food went cold, he'd finally amble over and pick at it.

I wanted to go out for a walk with him, and he'd say, "It's cold out, what's there to see," then the second Fiona said, "Dick, come play board games with me," he'd be pulling on his coat and out the door.

I thought maybe I was just too boring.

So I learned to game, dying again and again, the screen going gray over and over.

Fiona would laugh beside us. "Georgette, stop feeding the other team. Why don't you go watch a show instead."

He'd smirk. "Georgie, how are you this hopeless?"

So I learned board games, memorized the rules all night long, and still fumbled the whole game when it counted.

Fiona patted his shoulder. "How about you and me on a team? She's dead weight."

Dick sighed. "Forget it, don't force yourself."

Every way I tried to get closer to him, in their eyes, was nothing but a clumsy joke.

I wiped the corners of my eyes, shoved the last piece of clothing into the suitcase, and zipped it shut.

Dick walked in, a bag in his hand.

It was a box from the cake shop I loved.

He set the bag down beside the suitcase, crouched, and his voice came soft:

"Don't pack."

I didn't look at him.

He took the cake out, opened the box:

"Your favorite tiramisu. I drove all the way downtown for it. The snow was heavy. The roads were awful."

My hands went still.

"Georgie," he lifted his head, his eyes a little red,

"I've thought it over. I really did get too close to Fiona. I'll be careful. From now on I'll keep my distance from her, just the distance of an ordinary classmate."

"Don't go, okay?"

I said nothing, only stared at the wheels on the suitcase.

The scuffs and dents on them, every single one was a road I'd traveled back and forth.

He yanked me into his arms, his chin resting on the top of my head,

"When I come home, we'll get married. How about that?"

I closed my eyes.

The next day, Dick said something he'd never said before:

"Let's catch a movie today. The one you said you wanted to see."

That movie had been out for three months.

I'd said I wanted to see it three times. All three times, he forgot.

In the theater he was tender in a way he rarely was, handing me his jacket, shielding the seatback, sliding the popcorn over, every gesture pitched just right.

I almost talked myself into it.

He loved me. He was just careless.

When the movie let out, he held my hand, something he so seldom did.

I looked down at our laced fingers, but inside there was none of the warmth I'd imagined.

"Dick! Georgette! What a coincidence!"

Fiona came out of the theater next door, popcorn in her arms, her eyes crinkled with a smile.

Almost without realizing it, Dick let go of my hand.

"You came to see a movie too?"

He walked over, his tone turning easy.

"Yeah, I waited forever for this one!"

Fiona held the popcorn out to him. "Try some, it's caramel."

He took it, ate a piece, and then the two of them fell into conversation.

"I thought that twist at the end felt kind of forced."

"What do you know, that's the director's style—"

"Dick, can you not be such a contrarian?"

The more they talked, the more they laughed, their shoulders bumping together again.

I stood two steps away, looking at my empty hand.

All that tenderness in the theater just now, the second Fiona appeared, it vanished without a trace.

That was when it came. "Bang! " Several of them.

A burst of gunfire rang out from the far end of the corridor.

Screams exploded in an instant, the crowd scattering in every direction.

The flood of people shoved me forward, and on instinct I reached out to grab Dick.

He'd been a step ahead of me.

Fiona fell.

"Ah—!"

He heard her cry and whipped around.

I saw him glance at me, and then he flung my hand away.

He turned and ran toward Fiona.

I stood where I was, knocked back and forth by the crowd.

In the chaos I went down, hitting the floor, a raw, burning pain.

In that instant I suddenly remembered the summer after I turned eighteen, after the SATs.

The sunrise by Lake Geneva, the sky a pinkish purple.

He'd pulled me up onto the overlook, the two of us breathless, looking at each other, and then he took my hand and said:

"Georgie, I like you."

The tips of his ears had gone red as he spoke, his palm slick with sweat.

"Let's never let go of each other's hands, okay? Always like this, you by my side, me by yours."

I nodded, certain the whole world was right there in the palm of my hand.

But now the whole world was running.

And I was the only one still flat on the floor.

I don't know how long it lasted. The gunfire stopped. Sirens started.

I pushed myself up on one arm and limped out of the theater.

When I got home, the living room lights were on.

Dick was crouched on the floor, carefully dabbing ointment onto Fiona's calf.

"Hold on. This stings a little."

Fiona looked up, saw me, and gave a small smile. "Georgie, you okay? That was so terrifying. Thank God Dick reacted so fast."

Only then did Dick lift his head. "You're back? Good, as long as you're all right."

I looked down at myself.

A huge bruise spread across my knee. My elbow was still bleeding.

My hair hung loose around my face. I was a wreck from head to toe.

His gaze stayed on me for one second before it dropped back to Fiona's wound.

I wanted to demand an explanation, but by the time the words reached my lips, only one thought was left: he'd already chosen. He chose her.

In the second the gun went off, his body was ten thousand times more honest than his mouth.

"Georgie?" he called, finally noticing something was off. "What's wrong with you?"

I didn't answer.

I walked into the bedroom, opened the suitcase again, and packed the rest of my things.

He came after me. "Can you stop making a scene? In a situation like that, there was no way I could just leave her—"

"I know." I zipped the suitcase shut, my voice perfectly calm.

"So I made the choice for you."

"On the way back, I already booked a flight."

I looked up at him. "The earliest one. It leaves in two hours."

"Georgette—"

"Dick," I cut in. "Let's break up."

He tilted his head and clicked his tongue, impatient. "Georgette, every time you're upset you bring up breaking up. Can you act a little more grown-up? Cool off for a few days, and we'll talk."

I said nothing more. I picked up my suitcase, stepped past him, and walked out.

Dick didn't try to stop me. He just turned and went back to the living room.

Three days later, Dick sent a text. "Calmed down yet?"

No reply.

He sent another. "Where are you?"

A red exclamation mark.

He called. Phone off.

He bought a ticket and flew home immediately. Standing at the foot of her dorm building, he called her roommate.

"Where's Georgette? Tell her to come down."

The roommate's voice came out hesitant. "Georgie went to England on exchange. She didn't tell you?"

Dick froze.

The phone slipped from between his fingers and hit the ground with a sharp crack.