Heidi Matthews POV:
The hospital room had smelled of antiseptic and Arden' s tears. He hadn' t left my side, his hand clutching mine so tightly my knuckles were white.
"I almost lost you," he' d whispered into my hair, his body trembling. "Heidi, I swear, I will spend the rest of my life making this up to you. I will never, ever let you go."
He' d had nightmares for weeks, waking up shouting my name, his face slick with sweat. He' d hold me, telling me the thought of a world without me was a gaping black hole he couldn' t bear to look into.
That man, the one who looked at me like I was his entire world, felt like a ghost now. A phantom I had invented.
The old injury in my hip throbbed, a brutal metronome counting down the seconds of my life I had wasted. The physical pain was a dull echo of the emotional agony that was tearing me apart from the inside. I curled up in my bed, the vast, empty space beside me a cold reminder of his absence. The sobs came then, violent, silent tremors that shook my entire frame.
Dallas' s countdown continued, a relentless assault.
Wedding Countdown: 3 Days. It was a screenshot of her texts with Arden.
Him: Ditching her now. Meet me at the usual spot.
Her: My hero. I' ll be waiting.
The caption was sickeningly sweet: Sometimes being the other woman means you' re the only woman.
The comments were a mix of awe and speculation.
OMG where is he taking you?!
A private jet? A secret island? This is better than a movie!
I can't believe how much he loves you. He's risking everything.
A particularly sycophantic comment was pinned to the top: He is a man torn between duty and desire. His heart has chosen. You are his true north.
Just then, my phone rang. It was Arden.
"Hey, baby," he said, his voice breathless.
"Where are you?" I asked, my own voice a monotone.
"Just landed," he said. "Had to fly to Chicago for a last-minute client meeting. I feel terrible leaving you with all the wedding stuff."
He was panting slightly. I could hear the wind whistling in the background.
"Is the meeting that important?" I asked calmly. "More important than our wedding rehearsal tomorrow?"
There was a pause, and then a strange, muffled grunt on his end. "I… uh… yes. It is. I' m so sorry, Heidi. I' ll make it up to you, I promise."
Another sound, like a sharp intake of breath. Then the line went dead.
I didn' t have to wait long. Ten minutes later, lilypad_dreams updated.
It was a picture of Dallas, her hair windswept, standing on a balcony overlooking the ocean. It wasn' t Chicago. It was Montauk.
The caption: He called her while I was kissing his neck. He has to play the part, but he keeps whispering that I' m the only one he hears. I hope he remembers this moment, this feeling, forever.
The comments exploded.
This is the most tragically beautiful thing I' ve ever read.
My heart aches for you both.
For the next two days, their "last hurrah" played out on my phone screen. They were in Montauk, staying at a boutique hotel I recognized. They posted pictures of champagne on the beach, calling each other "My King" and "My Queen." They documented their final days of stolen passion before he was to be "shackled" to me.
I watched it all, my heart a frozen, dead thing in my chest. And I saved everything.
Finally, I picked up the phone and called my parents.
"Dad," I said, my voice cracking for the first time. "I need you."
I told them everything. The account. The dress. The three years of lies. The comment about my leg.
There was a long silence on the other end of the line. Then my father, Glen Barnett, spoke, his voice a low, dangerous rumble.
"You just tell me what you need, sweetheart. You just tell me, and it' s done."
"I have a plan," I said. "I just need you to trust me. And I need you to make sure the presentation screens in the Plaza ballroom are working perfectly."
The day of the wedding arrived, a perfect, crisp October Saturday. While hairdressers and makeup artists were setting up in the bridal suite I would never use, I was at JFK, boarding a flight to Paris. "For a much-needed vacation," I'd told my parents. They'd simply nodded, my father's hand squeezing my shoulder.
Back at the Plaza, the Grand Ballroom was a sea of New York' s elite. The Ellis and Matthews families, titans of finance and real estate, were finally uniting.
Arden arrived, looking impossibly handsome in his Tom Ford tuxedo. He was followed minutes later by Dallas, a vision in her blush-pink maid of honor dress. She looked radiant, but my mother, who missed nothing, later told me she saw a faint smudge of red lipstick on the corner of Arden' s mouth that perfectly matched Dallas' s.
His mother, Eleanor Ellis, a woman for whom appearances were everything, descended on him like a hawk. "Arden, where have you been? And for God' s sake, wipe your mouth. You look like a clown."
Arden, flustered, scrubbed at his lips. A sudden, cold unease washed over him. He realized he hadn' t seen Heidi. He hadn' t spoken to her in two days. He had assumed she was busy, angry, sulking. He had assumed she would be here. Waiting for him.
He looked for me in the crowd, his heart starting to beat a little faster. He told himself it was just wedding day jitters.
The string quartet began to play. The guests took their seats. The officiant took his place. The enormous doors at the back of the ballroom opened.
The host, a polished man with a booming voice, announced, "Ladies and gentlemen, please rise for the bride."
Arden stood at the altar, a perfect smile plastered on his face. He felt a prickle of unease. He looked over at Dallas, who stood primly in her spot. She gave him a tiny, conspiratorial smile. A secret shared between them.
He saw my parents, Glen and Maria Matthews, seated in the front row. Their faces were grim, but they were here. That had to mean something. He felt a wave of relief. Everything was fine. Heidi was just being dramatic, making an entrance.
"And now," the host boomed again, his voice echoing slightly in the vast room, "our beautiful bride, Heidi Matthews!"
The doors remained empty. A nervous murmur rippled through the crowd. The host cleared his throat, looking toward the event planner, who just shrugged, her face pale.
"Heidi Matthews?" the host called out again, his voice now laced with uncertainty.
And then, the ballroom plunged into darkness.
Gasps echoed through the room. Arden' s heart leaped into his throat.
The two massive screens on either side of the altar, the ones meant to display a romantic slideshow of our life together, flickered to life.
But it wasn't our faces that appeared.
It was the profile page of a private Instagram account: lilypad_dreams.
A collective intake of breath swept through the room.
Then, the first image filled the screen. Dallas, smiling blissfully, wearing my wedding dress, my veil. The caption burned in white letters against the black background: A secret ceremony for a secret love. Forever starts now.
The presentation began to play. A curated slideshow of their entire sordid affair. The picture of Arden' s hand holding the pearl from my veil. The bolognese he' d cooked for her. The Montauk trip. The text messages. Every post, every secret, every lie, broadcast in high definition for all of New York society to see.
The final slide was a screenshot of the comment section. The vile suggestion that someone should "accidentally" break my leg.
And right underneath it, highlighted in a damning red circle, was the single, crucial 'like' from the account's owner.
From lilypad_dreams.
Heidi Matthews POV:
From a first-class seat 30,000 feet over the Atlantic, I imagined the scene. The curated presentation looped, a silent, damning indictment playing over and over on the giant screens. The photo of Dallas in my dress. The kiss against the chinoiserie wallpaper. The screenshot of Arden' s text: Ditching her now. The close-up of him kissing Dallas' s ring. And finally, the grotesquely 'liked' comment about my leg. Over and over. A digital guillotine, rising and falling on their social standing.
The whispers in the ballroom must have grown into a roar.
"Is that… Dallas Mckinney?"
"In Heidi' s dress? Before the wedding?"
"My God, they had their own 'wedding night' ?"
"Look at that last one… she liked a comment about hurting Heidi? That' s not a love triangle, that' s psychotic."
On the altar, Arden and Dallas stood frozen, their faces turning from disbelief to horror. The blood drained from Arden' s face, leaving him a ghastly white. Dallas looked like she might faint.
"Shut it off!" Arden finally roared, his voice cracking with panic. He frantically waved at the tech booth. "Shut it off now!"
No one moved. The technicians had been given one, and only one, instruction from my father. Let it play.
My parents, Glen and Maria Matthews, sat stone-faced in the front row. Their expressions were glacial. Eleanor Ellis, Arden' s mother, rushed to my mother' s side, her face a mask of confusion and horror.
"Maria, what is this? Where is Heidi?"
My mother simply turned her head and looked at Eleanor, a look of such profound contempt on her face that Eleanor physically recoiled.
Arden, finally realizing I wasn't coming, that this was no dramatic entrance but a public execution, turned on Dallas. He grabbed her arm, his fingers digging into her flesh, and yanked her from the bridal party line.
"What did you do?" he hissed, his voice a venomous whisper loud enough for the front rows to hear. "What is this? That account was private!"
Dallas just shook her head, tears streaming down her face, mascara beginning to run in black tracks. She couldn' t speak. All she could do was stare at the screen, at her secret world laid bare for everyone to see. Her triumphant narrative, the one where she was the tragic heroine, had been twisted into a portrait of a malicious, social-climbing backstabber.
She had wanted to be the star of the show. She had just never imagined it would be this show. In her mind, she had been winning. She had the man, she had the secret love story. She had posted those things to revel in her victory, to have a private testament to the fact that she, not Heidi Matthews, was the one truly loved. She never thought the anonymous audience she had courted would ever merge with the real world. She never thought I would see.
The guests, seeing the drama was over and the scandal was just beginning, started to quietly file out, their phones already buzzing as the story began to spread like wildfire through the city' s elite circles.
Soon, only the three families remained in the vast, empty ballroom, the silent screens still glowing with their shame.
My father stood up. The sound of his chair scraping against the marble floor echoed like a gunshot. He walked slowly, deliberately, toward the altar.
CRACK.
His hand came down on a table laden with champagne glasses, the sound explosive in the silence. Glass shattered.
"You worthless piece of trash," he snarled, his eyes fixed on Arden. "You dare to do this to my daughter?"
Eleanor Ellis rushed forward. "Glen, please, there must be a misunderstanding…"
"A misunderstanding?" my father bellowed, turning his fury on her. "Your son has been carrying on an affair for three years with this… this creature! They defiled my daughter' s wedding dress, plotted behind her back, and this one," he pointed a trembling finger at Dallas, "wished her physical harm. And you call it a misunderstanding?"
"The engagement is off," my father declared, his voice ringing with finality. "The partnership between Matthews Corp and Ellis Financial is over. We are done."
Arden' s eyes went wide with genuine terror. The marriage wasn' t just about love; it was a dynasty-sealing merger. "No, Mr. Matthews, please," he begged, his voice pathetic. "I can fix this. Where is Heidi? I need to talk to her."
"You will never speak to my daughter again," my father said, his voice dropping to a deadly calm. He turned his gaze to Dallas' s parents, who had stood silently, looking ashen.
"And you," he said to Dallas' s father, a man he had once saved from ruin. "This is how you repay my kindness? By raising a snake who bites the hand that fed your entire family?"
Dallas' s mother, a woman perpetually cowed by her husband' s scandal, finally found her voice. "It wasn' t Dallas' s fault alone! Your son, Eleanor, he pursued her! He filled her head with lies!"
"My son would never have looked twice at a girl from a family with a jailbird for a father if she hadn' t thrown herself at him!" Eleanor shrieked back, her refined composure shattering into a million pieces.
The parents began to scream at each other, a vicious, ugly feud erupting over the wreckage of the wedding. Accusations flew. Insults about financial ruin and moral bankruptcy were hurled across the empty ballroom.
Arden ignored them. He pulled out his phone, his fingers shaking as he tried to call me. My number was blocked. He tried WhatsApp. Blocked. He tried every social media platform. Blocked. Blocked. Blocked.
A primal fear, cold and suffocating, seized him. He had always assumed I was a constant, a given. He had his fun with Dallas, the thrill of the illicit affair, but I was his future. Stable, powerful, respectable Heidi. He had believed he could have both. He had believed the secret would stay a secret forever. He believed I would always be there.
The thought that I was truly gone, that I had orchestrated this entire demolition of his life and simply walked away, was more terrifying than his father' s anger or his mother' s hysterics.
He ran out of the Plaza, hailing a cab to my apartment. He hammered on the door, shouting my name. He knelt on the cold marble floor of the hallway, a pathetic, broken figure. My building' s security, under strict orders from my father, dragged him away. He ended up at my parents' townhouse, where he actually knelt on the sidewalk outside, begging to be let in. My father sent the security team out, and they didn' t bother being gentle.
Dallas was dragged home by her parents and locked in her room.
By evening, the video of the wedding presentation was leaked online. It went viral. The story was everywhere. The anonymous gossip had a face now, and the public was ravenous.
At first, the narrative Dallas had so carefully built still had some supporters.
Maybe she was just venting. It' s hard being the other woman.
Heidi Matthews is the daughter of Glen Barnett, the real estate tycoon. Of course she' s a monster.
But then the full context emerged. The saved life. The family bailout. The sheer, calculated cruelty of it all.
Dallas, locked in her room, saw the tide turning against her online. She saw the comments on her own public page turning vicious. But she also saw a flicker of hope. A few die-hard romantics still defended her.
She' s just a girl in love. We' ve all done crazy things for love.
That was all she needed. She wasn' t done fighting. She would not go down without a war. She would take this fight to the court of public opinion and win back her narrative.
Her fingers flew across her phone screen, crafting a new post. A tear-stained selfie. The ultimate performance of her life was about to begin.
Dallas Mckinney POV:
I' m sorry. I' m so, so sorry. I never meant for anyone to get hurt. Love is a messy, complicated thing. It doesn' t follow rules. It just… is. They' ve been together forever, yes, but it' s a relationship of habit, of expectation. He felt trapped. I was his escape. His comfort. What was I supposed to do? Turn away the only man I' ve ever loved? For years, I' ve had to watch him with her, my best friend. The perfect daughter of the perfect family. I was just the girl from the wrong side of the tracks, the one with the tainted last name. The little maid of honor, always in her shadow. Is it so wrong to want a little bit of that light for myself? Is it so wrong to fight for a love that feels like destiny?
The post went up on a new, public account. It was a masterpiece of victimhood. I didn't name Heidi directly, just "my best friend," the "perfect daughter." I was the relatable underdog, the "personal maid" to the princess, the Jane Eyre to Heidi' s Blanche Ingram.
The internet ate it up. My new account gained thousands of followers in an hour. The comments were a tidal wave of support.
We stand with you, Dallas!
Don' t let the rich girl bully you! Her family' s money doesn' t make her right!
This is a classic enemies-to-lovers story in the making! You and Arden are endgame!
I felt a surge of triumph. I could still win this. I could still be the heroine.
Heidi Matthews POV:
I was sitting in a café on the Rue de Rivoli, a croissant untouched on my plate, watching Dallas' s pathetic little drama unfold on my phone. It was almost funny. She was doubling down on a losing hand, convinced she could manipulate the entire world the way she had manipulated Arden and me.
My father had called, livid. "I'll shut her down. I'll have my legal team bury her in lawsuits."
"No, Dad," I'd said calmly. "Don't. This is my fight. Let me handle it."
I opened my own Instagram, an account I rarely used, mostly for posting architectural photos. I started a new post. I didn' t write a long, emotional paragraph. I didn't have to. I had receipts.
First, a screenshot of a text exchange between Arden and me from our anniversary.
Him: Happy Anniversary to the woman who saved my life and gave me a new one. I love you more than words can say.
Me: I love you more.
Next, a photo of the deed to the Tribeca loft I had bought and designed for Dallas as a college graduation gift. A gift worth millions.
Then, a screenshot of my credit card statement, showing the five-figure charge for the custom haute couture gown I' d bought for her to wear as my maid of honor.
Finally, a picture of a delicate diamond necklace on a velvet tray. A gift from me to her from two years ago. The caption on my original post had read: For my sister, my other half. Because you deserve to sparkle.
I wrote a simple headline for the post: On being betrayed by your childhood sweetheart and your 'sister.' A short story in four parts.
I hit 'share.'
Then I finished my croissant.
The internet went into a frenzy. My post was a nuclear bomb dropped on Dallas' s pity party. The narrative didn't just tilt; it shattered.
Wait. That's the 'loveless, obligatory' relationship?
Heidi BOUGHT her a damn loft? And Dallas called herself a 'personal maid'? THE AUDACITY.
This isn't a tragic romance. This is a story about a narcissistic, ungrateful parasite and a weak-willed cheater.
Dallas Mckinney is a snake. A literal snake.
#CancelDallasMckinney
The tide turned with a vengeance. Dallas' s account was flooded with snake emojis and vicious comments. She quickly deleted her tear-stained post and then scrubbed her entire account, but it was too late. People had already screen-recorded everything. Her panicked deletion only served as an admission of guilt.
The name 'Dallas Mckinney' became a synonym for 'treacherous backstabber' in our social circle. Mothers told their daughters to stay away from her. Old friends blocked her number. She was a pariah.
Her father, enraged by the public humiliation and the fresh dredging up of his own past crimes, screamed at her for days. "I'm sending you to our cousins in Australia," he finally decided. "You will disappear until this blows over."
That night, my phone rang. It was Dallas. Her voice was a wreck, thick with hysterical sobs.
"Heidi, I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. Please, you have to help me. I was just... I was bewitched. I love him so much, I couldn't control it. I never wanted to destroy our friendship. I swear."
I let her cry, the sound tinny and pathetic through the phone.
"I never wanted to hurt you," she sobbed.
"Then why did you like the comment, Dallas?" I asked, my voice as cold and flat as a frozen lake. "The one about someone breaking my leg."
She gasped, a choked, terrified sound. "No! I didn't mean to! It was a mistake, my thumb must have slipped! The fans were so emotional, I didn't know how to explain..."
"The fans you cultivated with your lies?" I cut her off. "Dallas, I gave you everything. A home. My friendship. My family treated you like a daughter. Was none of that real to you?"
"It was!" she insisted. "It was real, but..."
"But you would have been happier if Arden didn't want to marry me, right?" I asked, my voice soft. "If he had chosen you instead?"
There was a telling pause. And then, a strange sound. She was laughing. A broken, unhinged giggle.
"Yes," she hissed, the victim mask dropping to reveal the bitter envy beneath. "Is that what you want to hear? Yes! I hate you, Heidi! I hate your perfect life, your perfect family, the way you walk into a room and everyone looks at you. I hate that you're so damn talented and confident and that you never seem to break a sweat. Your kindness feels like charity! Your friendship feels like a consolation prize! I wanted to be you! And since I couldn't be you, I wanted to have the one thing you loved most."
The venom in her voice was shocking, but it was also clarifying. It was never about love. It was about winning.
"My father," I said slowly, "risked his reputation and a significant amount of capital that he could have lost, to save your family from bankruptcy and your father from a longer prison sentence. He did it because his best friend, your grandfather, begged him to on his deathbed. He did it for a friendship that spanned fifty years. And this is how you repay him."
I didn't wait for a response. I hung up the phone.
I sat there in the Parisian twilight, the city lights beginning to glitter outside my window. I took a deep breath, the air cool and clean. I thought of my father, his unwavering integrity, his fierce loyalty. A wave of shame washed over me. For years, I had taken his love for granted, been so wrapped up in my own little world with Arden and Dallas. I had been a fool, and I had been a careless daughter.
A week later, I was sketching in the Jardin du Luxembourg when a voice called my name.
"Heidi?"
I looked up. It was Arden. He looked terrible. His suit was rumpled, his eyes were red-rimmed and bloodshot, and he had a dark stubble on his jaw. He looked like he hadn't slept in a week.
"What are you doing here?" I asked, my voice devoid of any emotion.
"I came to find you," he said, his voice hoarse. He took a step closer. "Heidi, don't you know how worried I've been? How could you do that? How could you humiliate me, humiliate us, like that?"
I just stared at him, my pen still in my hand.
"Have you developed amnesia, Arden?" I asked coolly.
He flinched, shame finally coloring his face. "No, I... I know. I messed up. I messed up so badly, Heidi. But it was just... it was a mistake. Dallas was going through a lot, and I was just trying to... to make her feel better. To give her a little fantasy before I married you."
"A fantasy?" I repeated, my voice dripping with ice.
"Yes! Because you're the one I want to spend my life with! You're the one who is my equal, who understands my world. Dallas... she has nothing. No family name, no prospects. I was just trying to give her a nice memory, a little fairytale to hold onto. As her friend, as our friend, you should understand that!"
A dry, mirthless laugh escaped my lips. "Understand? You want me to understand?"
I stood up, closing my sketchbook. "Then you should have no problem making her fairytale permanent. Go marry her, Arden."
He recoiled as if I'd slapped him. "What? No! I can't marry her! Her father… he has a criminal record! The Ellis family can't be associated with that. You know that!"
He stopped, his eyes widening in horror as he realized what he'd just admitted.
"There it is," I said softly. "The truth. You look down on her. You use her for a cheap thrill, but you would never tarnish your precious family name by actually marrying her. You wanted her in your bed, but me on your arm. You are a hypocrite, a coward, and a user."
I looked at him, at the man I had once loved enough to trade my body for his safety, and all I felt was a profound, bottomless disgust.
"I used to love you," I said, the words tasting like ash. "Now, when I look at you, I feel nothing but contempt."
"No, Heidi, don't say that!" he pleaded, his voice breaking. "I love you. It's always been you."
"Your love is worthless, Arden," I said, turning to walk away. "The engagement is over. The life we were supposed to have is over. Now, please, do me one last favor and disappear from my life."
He fell to his knees right there on the gravel path of the Jardin du Luxembourg. "Heidi, please! Don't do this! Twenty-five years! Our families! I saved your life! You can't just throw all that away!"
I paused, but I didn't turn around. I let him kneel there, a pathetic monument to his own destruction.
When I got back to my hotel, there was a message from my mother. Dallas' s father had shown up at their house, with Dallas in tow, to beg for forgiveness. I played along, my voice sweet and forgiving on the phone. I told Dallas's father I understood, that young love was complicated, and that I would step aside to let the two 'soulmates' be together.
Then, just as he was sighing in relief, I added, "It's just so tragic that Arden feels he can't marry her. He told me himself, he could never be with a woman whose family name was tainted by a criminal conviction. He said he looked down on her."
I made my voice a conspiratorial whisper, just loud enough for Dallas, who was surely listening, to hear. I described exactly what Arden had said to me in the garden, about her having no prospects, about her father being a jailbird.
I imagined the look on Dallas's face. The look on her father's face.
The war was no longer mine to fight. It was theirs.